When it comes to tactical knives, the market is flooded with options. But not every knife labeled “tactical” deserves the title. So, what exactly makes a knife tactical, and how do you choose the right one? Whether you’re picking up your first piece of gear or adding to an already solid collection, it’s important to understand what separates a good tactical knife from the rest.
Defining a Tactical Knife
There’s no official rulebook defining a tactical knife, but there are key features that set them apart. First and foremost is the grip. A tactical knife needs a handle that you can rely on in all conditions—wet, cold, with or without gloves. The grip material should be aggressive enough to ensure it stays in your hand, no matter what.
Speed is another factor. In a high-pressure situation, you might only have one hand free. A tactical knife should open quickly and easily with one hand so you can stay focused on the task at hand. The blade itself should be designed with a specific purpose in mind. Whether it’s for self-defense, utility, or something more specialized, the blade needs to be made from quality steel that can handle the job.
It’s kind of an inexact definition. You know one when you see one. This reminds me of something Spyderco Sal Glesser said once, “A tactical knife is any knife you have with you when you need a knife.”
With all blades, you want to get the most bang for your buck. Tactical knives come at all price points, but the goal is to find one that balances cost with performance. You don’t need to spend a fortune to get a reliable blade, but you do need to know what to look for.
Testing the Best Tactical Knives
When it comes to recommending tactical knives, experience matters. Our team comes from a mix of military, law enforcement, and everyday carry backgrounds. We’ve spent thousands of hours working with knives, not just in the field but in the day-to-day grind where reliability counts.
We’ve narrowed down our list based on three key criteria: grip material, ease of one-handed opening, and blade purpose. We also factored in value because a good knife doesn’t have to break the bank.
Best Overall Tactical Knife: Sniper Bladeworks MAMU
If you’re looking for a versatile, reliable fixed-blade knife, the Sniper Bladeworks MAMU is a top pick. Priced under $200, it offers great value without sacrificing quality. The 420HC stainless steel blade may not be the latest and greatest, but it’s proven itself over time. It’s easy to sharpen, holds up well against corrosion, and can handle abrasion like a champ.
The Sniper Bladeworks MAMU stands out as an excellent choice if you want a versatile and reliable fixed-blade knife. (Gear Junkie)
The MAMU also comes with a customizable injection-molded sheath that features a DOTS belt clip, a favorite among military and law enforcement. The sheath’s design allows you to mount the knife in any direction, whether on your belt or pack strap, giving you flexibility in how you carry it. The knife’s ergonomics are also noteworthy, providing a comfortable grip that reduces fatigue, even during extended use.
Pros
Versatile Design: The MAMU’s full-tang construction and ergonomic grip make it suitable for various tasks, from slicing to chopping.
Durable Steel: 420HC stainless steel is easy to sharpen, corrosion-resistant, and resistant to wear and tear.
Customizable Sheath: The injection-molded sheath with a DOTS belt clip allows for multiple carry orientations, providing flexibility for tactical applications.
Value for Money: Priced under $200, it offers high-quality performance without breaking the bank.
Cons
Blade Steel: While 420HC is reliable, it doesn’t hold an edge as long as some higher-end steels, requiring more frequent sharpening.
Weight: The knife’s robust design makes it slightly heavier, which might be a downside for those looking for a lighter option.
Best Folding Tactical Knife: Benchmade Redoubt
For those who prefer a folding knife, the Benchmade Redoubt is an excellent choice. Originally available with gray Grivory handle scales, Benchmade recently released a Blackout version with black handle scales and a textured inlay for added grip. Both versions feature a Cerakoted CPM D2 drop-point blade, making them well-suited for tactical applications.
The Benchmade Redoubt features a Cerakoted CPM D2 drop-point blade, making it well-suited for tactical applications. (Nothing But Knives)
The Redoubt is a solid performer. It’s designed along the lines of Benchmade’s iconic Griptilian series, so it has a familiar feel if you’ve used that line before. The Cerakote finish on the blade helps it glide through wet or sticky materials with ease, and cleanup is a breeze. The Redoubt is a great example of what a tactical folder should be—reliable, durable, and easy to carry.
Pros
Reliable Blade Material: The Cerakoted CPM D2 blade offers excellent wear resistance and toughness, making it suitable for demanding tasks.
Comfortable Grip: The textured handle scales provide a secure grip, even in wet conditions.
Smooth Operation: The blade glides effortlessly through various materials, and the knife is easy to clean after use.
Versatility: Designed as an EDC and tactical tool, it’s adaptable to various situations.
Cons
Price: Benchmade knives tend to be on the higher end of the price spectrum, which may be a drawback for those on a tight budget.
Blade Finish: While the Cerakote finish is durable, it may wear over time, especially with heavy use.
Best Automatic Tactical Knife: Benchmade Claymore Tanto
Automatic knives can be tricky, especially in the civilian world, where laws vary by state. But if you’re in law enforcement or the military, the Benchmade Claymore Tanto is a solid option. This knife was designed with tactical situations in mind, offering a lightweight but durable build that’s perfect for everyday carry or self-defense.
The Claymore, made from coated CPM D2 tool steel with Grivory handles, boasts a solid size-to-weight ratio and is built for durability. (Gear Junkie)
Made from coated CPM D2 tool steel with Grivory handles, the Claymore has a great size-to-weight ratio and is built to last. The spring-assisted opening mechanism is strong and reliable, ensuring the blade deploys quickly when you need it. Benchmade considers the Claymore their toughest folder yet, and after putting it through its paces, I’m inclined to agree.
Pros
Quick Deployment: The powerful spring-assisted mechanism ensures rapid blade deployment with the press of a button.
Tough Build: The Claymore is made from CPM D2 tool steel and Grivory handles, and it is designed to withstand heavy use.
Ergonomics: The handle design protects the hand and ensures a firm grip, even during intense tasks.
Compact and Lightweight: Despite its robust build, the Claymore has an excellent size-to-weight ratio, making it easy to carry.
Cons
Legal Restrictions: Automatic knives are restricted in many states, limiting who can legally carry them.
Complex Mechanism: The automatic opening system requires careful maintenance to ensure long-term reliability.
Best Bushcraft and Tactical Combo: Zero Tolerance 0006
If you need a knife that can handle both tactical tasks and outdoor survival, the Zero Tolerance 0006 is a strong contender. Zero Tolerance is known for their overbuilt designs, and the 0006 is no exception. With a Cerakoted CPM 3V blade and chunky G10 handle scales, this knife is ready for anything.
The Zero Tolerance 0006 comes with a Kydex sheath that offers multiple carry options, whether you’re heading into the wilderness or onto the battlefield. (Gear Junkie)
At just under 11 inches, it’s a bit shorter than some combat knives, but that makes it more versatile. The included Kydex sheath allows for multiple carry options, whether you’re heading into the wilderness or onto the battlefield. The 0006 is a knife that blurs the lines between categories, making it a great choice for anyone who needs a blade that can do it all.
Pros
Rugged Construction: The Cerakoted CPM 3V blade and G10 handle scales make the 0006 extremely durable and capable of handling tough tasks.
Versatility: Suitable for both bushcraft and tactical use, making it a great all-around knife.
Customizable Carry Options: The included Kydex sheath offers multiple carry configurations, adding to its practicality in the field.
Long Blade: The long drop-point blade is excellent for cutting, slicing, and other outdoor tasks.
Cons
Price: At $400, the 0006 is a significant investment, which may be out of reach for some users.
Weight and Size: The knife is on the heavier side, which might be a disadvantage for those looking for a more lightweight option.
Ergonomics: While durable, the handle lacks some modern ergonomic features, which could make extended use less comfortable.
How to Choose the Best Tactical Knife
Choosing the right tactical knife depends on what you need it for. Here’s a quick breakdown of the different types of tactical knives:
Automatic Knives: These knives deploy at the press of a button, offering quick access in urgent situations.
Pocket Knives: Compact and foldable, these are ideal for everyday carry.
Fixed-Blade Knives: Sturdy and reliable, perfect for outdoor activities or survival situations.
Assisted Knives: These feature a mechanism that helps to open the blade quickly, blending manual control with ease of use.
Carry Knives: Designed for easy and discreet carry, ensuring you’re always ready without drawing attention.
After you’ve identified the type of knife you need, consider these factors:
Material: High-quality steel is essential for a good tactical knife. Look for materials like 440C, VG-10, S30V stainless steel, or high-carbon steels like D2 or CPM-S35VN.
Size & Weight: If you plan to carry the knife every day, size matters. Make sure it fits your needs, and check local regulations for legal carry sizes.
Ease of Use: Whether it’s an automatic knife or a manual one, make sure it’s easy to operate. And always check your local laws to ensure it’s something you’re allowed to carry.
Safety: A reliable locking mechanism is crucial to keep the blade secured.
Brand Recognition: Stick with reputable brands that offer a warranty for peace of mind.
Budget: You don’t have to spend a fortune to get a good knife, but it’s important to find one that offers good value for the price.
Final Thoughts
The world of tactical knives is broad, but that doesn’t mean every option is worth your time. Knowing what to look for in terms of grip, speed, blade design, and value will help you make a more informed choice.
Whether you’re looking for a knife to carry every day, something for the field, or a blade that can do both, there’s a tactical knife out there that fits the bill. Just make sure to consider your needs, do your research, and choose a knife that won’t let you down when it counts.
